Book Vs. Movie "Smoke Signals"

Book Vs. Movie: Smoke Signals

The Sherman Alexie Short Story Vs. the 1998 Movie

In this episode, the Margos delve into the acclaimed indie film Smoke Signals, released in 1998. This film was based on a series of short stories by Sherman Alexie in 1993, titled The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven. The story follows two young men, Victor Joseph and Tom Builds-the-Fire, who grew up on a Spokane Indian Reservation. It explores the interconnectedness of their families, the perception of Native Americans in mainstream media, and the truth behind Tom's father's death.

Smoke Signals was well-received by critics and audiences alike and was showcased at various film festivals such as the Sundance Film Festival, the Gotham Awards, and the Independent Spirit Awards. In 2018, it was even added to the National Film Registry. Chris Eyre directed the movie, which was based on Alexie's screenplay.

We'll also be discussing our personal preferences between the two. Come and join this discussion.

Calm History:

If you want to learn about curious moments from history while lowering your stress, try the new podcast Calm History. Each episode is narrated in a calm voice to help you to relax or fall asleep. You’ll enjoy learning about famous explorers, leaders, athletes, inventions, civilizations, and ancient wonders. There is even a 6-part series about The Titanic. Search your podcast player for Calm History, or use the link to calmhistory.com in the episode notes.

In this ep, the Margos discuss:

The controversies of writer Sherman Alexie
The history of how America treats Indigenous people. (Big hint--not great!)
The differences between Alexie’s short stories and the film
The cast of the 1998 film: Adam Beach (Victor Joseph,) Evan Adams (Thomas Builds-the-Fire,) Irene Bedard (Suzy Song,) Gary Farmer (Arnold Joseph,) John Trudell (Randy Peone,) Michael Greyeyes (Junior Polatkin,) Michelle St. John (Velma,) Elaine Miles (Lucy,) Cynthia Geary (Cathy the gymnast,) Perrey Reaves (Holly,) Molly Cheek (Penny Cicero,) Robert Maino (Burt Cicero,) and Tom Skerrit as the police chief.